John Ferneyhough of Bolton on Dearne died on 24 September 2004 while trying to lift the excavator using a lorry-mounted crane. The hook attachment on the crane failed while the excavator was suspended above the lorry.

HSE Inspector David Stewart said: "The risks involved in lifting operations and workplace transport should never be underestimated. It is vital that lifting equipment is effectively maintained and lifting operations are planned properly to ensure workers' and public safety.

"The underlying cause of this accident was the company's poor maintenance regime for its lorry loader cranes which meant that on the day in question the crane involved was not in a condition fit for use because of earlier damage to the hook.

"Employers have a duty to ensure that their plant is safely maintained. Failure to do this can have tragic consequences as this accident has demonstrated all too clearly."