Welcoming the decision, Simon Thurley, chief executive of English Heritage, said:

“We are delighted that the Secretary of State has, by virtue of the decision to refuse conservation area consent for the demolition of the General Market Building and planning permission for the proposed replacement scheme, recognised the value of the Smithfield conservation area. 

“At a time when there is increasing concern about sustainability and the sensible use of resources and energy, it would be irresponsible to demolish a building like this. 

“We are disappointed that the Corporation of London’s good record for conservation of listed buildings has been undermined by their willingness to neglect these historic buildings and in doing so, disregarded national planning policy.  We now expect the Corporation to take the opportunity to bring forward a creative scheme for the repair and re-use of the General Market Building, Annex and Red House Cold Store, to enable them to fully contribute to the important conservation area in which they sit."